Friday, May 06, 2011

Obama Air Assault

I think Oliver North got it right here. The Administration and the USA would have been better off with a plain No Comment from Jay Carney,
All the White House had to do once they knew bin Laden was dead was to say nothing. That's the way it's supposed to be for covert operations. When asked, respond with: "No comment."

Such a course of action would no doubt result in extraordinary speculation. Photos of the tail section of a U.S. MH-60 helicopter and images of the dead taken by Pakistani authorities after the raid would still get published, and global "social networks" would be full of rumors, theories and supposition for weeks or months. But intricate details on intelligence means and methods, tactics, techniques and procedures, numbers of U.S. personnel involved and unique communications equipment and capabilities would remain matters of conjecture.

Inevitably, there would be unconfirmed "leaks" from officials in Washington and Islamabad. Yet, the message to America's enemies would still be the same. Be afraid. Be very afraid. After all, that is the reason we have JSOC.

A "we will not confirm or deny" statement from the White House in the aftermath of the JSOC operation would have made it more difficult in the short-term for Obama to appear "decisive" and "hands on." But years from now, when the full story was finally revealed, he would have been seen as more "presidential." It also would have made it easier for those friends we do have in Pakistan to continue cooperating with our military and intelligence services.
I think the US is going to pay a price somewhere along the line for this show of decisiveness. It's wrong on many levels. History won't find Air Assault shirts held up for the press Presidential.

Somber awe for what the United States wrought on a foe, the better response.

2 comments:

Matt said...

Totally agree there, Bill. It's descending into Hollywood.

Bill Baar said...

Thanks Matt.